Monday 27 February 2017

Flaws

Image credit.


Nick Johnson writes about A Flaw in Marx and Hayek, inciting me to make this comment:

Great quote. I like your comment. Thanks for drawing my attention to Hodgson’s (for me new) blog, and his forthcoming book, which appears to focus on a topic that I find myself rather preoccupied with.

At a time when I open up to the ideas of the left, I discover that the left has spectacularly betrayed its great concerns and its clientèle in the past 30 years (and, like the pope, borrowed green ideology to lend religious oomph to its various postures). Why did this happen? 

I feel like I’ve come too late to the party — the sensible ideas of the left, like demand management and opposition to neo-liberalism and their chief concern for the working population, are no longer fashionable with them. It strikes me as vital that the left begin to turn a critical eye to their own surprising vicissitude.

Also, I used to be a great admirer of Hayek; however, over the past years, I have become disillusioned with him — to the point where I almost look at Hayek as a charlatan. It is interesting how acceptance of only a few key assumptions — for instance that a good society must be a spontaneous order and conscious interference in that order must be mostly detrimental — can blind a person to many important insights of differing implications and make her inclined to take dubitable propositions for deep insights by virtue of their fitting into an expected pattern of explanations.

I have summarised much of my criticism of Hayek in a series of posts under the title The Paradox of Freedom: http://quaesivi.blogspot.de/2016/03/the-paradox-of-freedom-1-austrian.html

No comments:

Post a Comment